Categories
Collaborations Event recaps Listen Read

Composing “Lazy-bop”

This month, our team had an interesting challenge, to devise a short workshop for the F2F Music Foundation’s summer camp, which serves underprivileged kids in the Houston area. The camp supports youths in developing and honing instrumental performance skills. F2F’s founder, the multifaceted Hammond organist and composer Vel Lewis, was keen to give the campers hands-on experience with technology while introducing them to Hyperscore as a tool for composition. And he wanted the campers to produce an original piece that would be performed on instruments during the camp’s final concert. 

The campers range in age from seven to 17, and several participated in last year’s summer camp, so they would be able to help the novices with Hyperscore basics. But what could we do in the few hours allotted to the workshop that would be rewarding and relevant? 

The camp has a jazz orientation, so we decided to start with a jazzy melody. The campers’ job would be to add accompanying melodies, bass, and percussion. While the idea sounded good in theory, we had not actually tried it out ourselves. So that’s what we decided to do at this month’s Second Sunday Zoom workshop. We composed a bebop-inspired melody in advance. Here it is:

This is what it looks like transcribed into Hyperscore:

While easy on the ears, it’s rhythmically complex, with grace notes, syncopation—elements that make a melody “swing.” We decided to start by adding a bass line, something that could underpin the melody by marking the beat against which the melody would be syncopated. We wondered whether there was a chordal structure to work from, but as we were racing against the clock, we said “let’s just use our ears.” (Plus, we don’t know the rules of jazz harmonies…) We started with a basic descending scale with some jumps, a few eighth notes thrown in among the quarter notes, and a little “grace note” beat at the very end of the phase so that when we looped it, there’d be a nice little flourish to propel us sonically into the next cycle.

Once we got a bass line that sounded good to us, we wanted to add a second melody that could weave in and out. Maybe something that “echoed” parts of the main melody. To make the “echo”, Peter copied part of the melody and plopped it into a new melody window, positioning it right after the trombone melody plays. We chose a vibraphone (yellow melody window) for the instrument because it is a bright sound that contrasts and complements the trombone nicely. 

Now onto percussion! Percussion often follows the rhythmic pattern of the melody. We heard in our heads a quarter beat alternating with triplet eights. Again, copying and pasting from the main melody into the percussion window saved some time. At first, the resulting beat sounded a bit too mechanical and lacking in swing, but upon listening, it wasn’t half bad. We adjusted the volume and changed to a cymbal with a more resonant vibration and liked that much better. We threw in some other percussion instruments at various points for emphasis:

We gave it a couple more listens and enjoyed what we heard! Here it is:

We realized afterward that the process we used was a great example of motific composing, in which we copied and pasted bits from the original melody to create the other parts. This was true even as we were guided only by what we heard, not by theory. 

Some pro tips: The original melody was locked using keyboard command Ctrl – shift – L (L for “lock”). That way we couldn’t accidentally change it. Also, if you watch the full video of how we created this piece, you’ll see how we stacked various windows with the bars aligned so that it was easy to see the time relationship among the different parts. 

Finally, while our team managed to collaboratively create our piece in one hour, we felt this would be a very challenging project for a workshop with kids. We decided to provide more supports, including showing the chords. Unfortunately, just as we were planning this camp workshop, Houston was hit hard by Hurricane Beryl, with electrical power for much of the city knocked out for days. The camp was postponed. We hope Vel and the kids are safe and look forward to composing with them in the near future.

Here’s the full video of our Second Sunday session:

Categories
Event recaps Read

Soundtracks for Robots

Does your robot have a name? What is its personality?

What journey has your robot been on? Where is it going?

These were some of the questions we asked the elementary and middle schoolers participating in a Junior Botball robotics camp this summer. The campers were surprised by our questions. They had been so intent all week on getting gears to mesh properly and software commands debugged, that they hadn’t thought about naming their robots at all. But the metal, plastic and rubber contraptions were soon given monikers and endowed with personalities that “keep going” and “want to get the job done.”

Warming up to the idea of creating music to tell their robots’ stories, the campers were soon working on percussion riffs. They explored the different sounds made by the Rhythm Window. We talked about how the beat establishes a personality–steady as clockwork or cautious and exploratory. If fast, the tempo conveys urgency. If slow, the mood might feel deliberate or even dangerous.

When they were satisfied with their beats, the campers tackled the next layer, melody. One camper had designed a dancing robot that cycled between twirling and moving back and forth. While the movements were repetitive, the music was anything but. The beat was spiky and the tune careened chaotically, triggering much joyful head bopping by the composer.

Once melody-making was well under way, we introduced the Sketch Window and discussed how the campers could assemble their melodies and rhythmic motifs into a larger story–much the way they had taken a pile of loose parts and snapped them together to construct their robots. Each robot was programmed to go through specified movements. The more advanced robots navigated through a maze, picking up balls, blocks, and “moon rocks” along the way and delivering them to the moon lander. The campers needed to think about their robots’ stories. How does it start? What happens in the middle? Are there moments of tension, for example when a robot is trying to carry out a tricky task? How does it end? In triumph or disappointment?

For the final layer, we introduced the harmony settings and Harmony Line, and encouraged the campers to try listening to their pieces in the None, General, and Classical harmony modes. Did they like one more than another? Soon the campers were oohing and exclaiming, visibly excited to realize Hyperscore had more powers for them to explore.

By the end of our three-hour workshop, each camper had completed an original composition for their robot. The final assignment was to edit videos of their robots and layer in the audio soundtrack, which they downloaded from Hyperscore as MP3 files. We look forward to seeing the videos soon on YouTube!

Recipe for success

The camp ran smoothly because the campers’ Hyperscore accounts had been set up in advance. We had also trained a group of high-school student mentors in Hyperscore ahead of time. The camp director had set up the campers’ daily routines in a way that fit their ebbing and flowing levels of energy and focus. The campers themselves had some experience with computers and algorithmic thinking, so it was easy for them to learn the interface and grasp the basic ideas behind motific composing.

What Hyperscore added to the robotics camp was a way for the campers and mentors — a dozen high-energy elementary, middle and high school kids — an opportunity to reflect on and express the emotions and ideas that were until then an undiscussed, unexplored dimension to their experience. They were all eager to participate and quickly became focused and engrossed in the composing activity.

We hope that our workshop awakened the campers to new facets of their own creative potential. One camper in particular made an impression on us. When he was working on his rhythm motifs, he kept frowning and shaking his head. It was the start of something but he wasn’t satisfied. He continued to work with focus and intention and composed a piece that had a ear-worm of a theme and an impressive build that effectively captured the robot’s drama. A composer is born!

We are grateful to camp director Elaine Griggs and the Junior BotBall Summer Camp through CS4Youth in Pembroke, MA. Thank you for welcoming us and giving us this wonderful opportunity to work with you.

Categories
Uncategorized

HER Achievement Award 2024

We at New Harmony Line are proud to announce that Cecilia Roudabush, our Director of Education, has been named by The Gazette as one of its 2024 HER Women of Achievement. We think she’s very special, and we’re glad to see others also recognize her extraordinary qualities. Following is an appreciation written by her daughter, Haley Roudabush.

Cecilia (Cece) Roudabush grew up in Creston, Iowa. She moved to Iowa City, earning her BA in Music Education & Therapy as well as her Masters in Music Therapy with a focus in Behavior Disorders. Cecilia delighted in working with students from grades K-12 for 32 years teaching general and adaptive music, rock band, success center and personal development. 

After retiring from full-time teaching in 2021, Cecilia has continued providing music composition opportunities to children all over the world through her work as the Director of Education for New Harmony Line. 

Since childhood, she has dedicated herself to many service projects in her community and church, including the free lunch program, working with Habitat for Humanity, and leading projects at St. Thomas More such as “Blanket Them With Love” for victims of the derecho and Afghani refugees in Cedar Rapids. 

Cecilia believes her greatest accomplishment in life has been bringing her two children into the world. Now adults, they have both followed in her footsteps and begun careers of service within their communities. If she has free time, you can be certain Cecilia is using it to help those around her. 

Cecilia thanks her friends, family and colleagues for their love, and this nomination for the HER Achievement Award.

Categories
News Uncategorized

AI and Hyperscore

By June Kinoshita, Executive Director, New Harmony Line

It seems like every education and arts conference this year is talking about Artificial Intelligence. Can generative AI be creative? Will it enhance or destroy creative industries, not to mention all kinds of jobs? One popular meme going around on social media says “I want AI to do my laundry and dishes so that I can do art and writing, not for AI to do my art and writing so that I can do my laundry and dishes.” Amen to that.

In fact, Hyperscore is an example of a software that uses AI to do the more tedious chores, freeing people to explore the fun, creative, and essential parts of composing. Centering human expression and creativity in technology design is the core principle of Hyperscore’s inventors at the Opera of the Future Group at the M.I.T. Media Lab. We believe it is becoming ever more urgent to uphold these values as societal and economic pressures threaten to push AI in the opposite direction.

A deeper dive

One of Hyperscore’s advanced features is the “harmony line,” the dark gray line that is centered on the horizontal axis of the Sketch Window. This line can be manipulated to create regions of harmonic tension, release, and modulation. The Hyperscore composer can play with the harmony line and decide whether the results sound the way they want them to. A more advanced composer can do this more intentionally, and of course they can always specify the exact notes they want in the Melody Window. Hyperscore allows a user to be fully in control of every note, or to collaborate playfully with its algorithms to discover and shape the elements of their composition.

Hyperscore’s automated harmony algorithm was originally implemented using AI trained on classical music. You can read the technical details in this article (Farbood, M., Kaufman, H., Jennings., K. “Composing with Hyperscore: An Intuitive Interface for Visualizing Musical Structure” International Computer Music Conference, 2007.) To quote:

“In Hyperscore, users describe harmonic progressions by shaping the harmony line. It is parsed into sections which are then mapped to functional identifiers…which consist of four categories: Statement, Antecedent, Consequent, and Modulation. The harmony line, which runs through the center of each sketch window, can be modified by clicking and dragging. Colored bands appear to indicate the line’s parsing. Sections are classified as one of four visual types, each corresponding to a functional identifier: 

• Statement – flat section, colored white. Musically defined as a statement or prolongation of the tonic. 

• Antecedent – upward-sloping section, colored green. Musically defined as a combination of chords that need resolution (e.g. dominant chords or combinations of subdominant and dominant chords). 

• Consequent – downward-sloping section, colored blue. Resolution of preceding Antecedent section. If not preceded by an Antecedent, then restates the tonic. 

• Modulation – defined by a sharp pointed region or spike, colored yellow. Progression toward a new key. 

After the line is parsed, chords are assigned to each section based on its functional identifier, how many beats it spans, and how textured or “bumpy” the section is. The instability of the chords assigned to a section is directly proportional to the amount of texture. The chords chosen are taken from a database that returns either single chords or small progressions based on the selection criteria. The database consists of chord progressions commonly found in Bach chorales.”

Explore Hyperscore

If you’re intrigued and want to play around with Hyperscore, you can sign up for a free version (with limited functionality) or a subscription version (starting at a very affordable $3.99 per month). You can also try out the full classroom version by signing up for the Hyperscore Challenge, which runs through June 21. 

To help you get started, we have Quick Tips that walk you through all of the features of Hyperscore. We also invite you to attend our free Second Saturday Zoom workshop where you can participate in composing a new Hyperscore piece in real time.

Image credit: “Better Sharing With AI” by Creative Commons was generated by the DALL-E 2 AI platform with the text prompt “A surrealist painting in the style of Salvador Dali of a robot giving a gift to a person playing a cello.” CC dedicates any rights it holds to the image to the public domain via CC0.

Categories
Listen News Watch

A Hyperscore jam with Orff instruments

by June Kinoshita, Executive Director, New Harmony Line

We’re constantly discovering new and wonderful ways to play with Hyperscore. Recently, Peter Torpey and I were invited to give a series of talks to music education masters students at the Longy School in Cambridge, MA. Their instructor, Garo Saraydarian, mentioned the students were in the middle of unit about Orff instruments. We had not thought about integrating Hyperscore compositions with Orff or any other type of acoustic instruments so we arrived in class without a plan.

We showed the basics of Hyperscore composition to the class of around a dozen students from diverse parts of the world and then turned them loose to compose. They worked in clusters of two to four students for about a half hour. Because all of them were already experienced in instrumental performance and theory, they could dive right in, although none of them had composed collaboratively before.

When the time was up, Garo asked each group to share their composition. And here’s when he made a simple but brilliant suggestion. After sharing the composition, they were asked to use Orff instruments to improvise an accompaniment to the Hyperscore piece.

The effect was utterly charming! The digital sound of Hyperscore set a foundation to which the students added a variety of expressive rattles, buzzes, and melodious metallophone sonorities. It was all so playful and everyone was pleased with the outcome. It was such a simple idea – any music teacher could replicate it–and yet captured the essence of music-making, with delightful results. Watch:

Categories
News

Meet the “wildlife DJ”

Chatting with Ben Mirin was one of those unforgettable meeting-of-minds moments. Ben has recorded a Noah’s ark of animal sounds in the wild and then remixes this non-human chorus with his own beat boxing. It’s entertaining, but it’s more than that. Ben is on a mission to use music to make people care deeply about our natural world–protecting endangered species and restoring habitats.

This resonated with us. One of the core ideas we emphasize in our work is “active listening” — opening up your ears to hear the world around you fully. We want you to become attuned to the wealth of information that sounds carry to our brains but also to become aware of the feelings these sounds stir in us.

In our 45-minute conversation, we cover some of the diversity of Ben’s output. He shares video from Indonesia of the amazing vocal prowess of male birds of paradise. We get to enjoy a video of Ben’s beatboxing video from the National Arts Center of Canada’s Great Orchestra Field trip, featuring sounds from the rainforests of Kalimantan. He walks us through “BeastBox,” a game he created with the Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology, where you too can be a wildlife DJ. (Visit Ben’s website and click on the BeastBox link.)

We talk about his journey using music technology to create his work. I ask about an idea to create a Hyperscore instrument set using bird songs with varied pitches and timbres and Ben launches into a discussion of the “acoustic niche hypothesis.”

Now working on his PhD at Cornell, Ben shares stories about his field research in Java, where there is a booming trade in songbirds. The local people prize their feathered divas, training and entering them in American Idol-style contests complete with judges, cheering spectators, and prize money that could support a family for ten years. It’s a big business that brings jobs and money into the local economy, and people are passionate about their birds, but it’s also having a devastating impact on wild bird populations. “We all love birds,” he says. He wants to build on the shared love of these wonderous creatures to “plant the seeds of conservation.”

Click on the image below to watch.

Categories
Listen Uncategorized

“Dance of the Fireflies”

The inspiration for our Second Saturday composition last month was this remarkable photograph of a nighttime forest illuminated by countless fireflies. We shared the image over Zoom and for two minutes we each wrote down words evoked by this vision.

To begin creating our composition, we began with a percussion window. Imagining all of those fireflies flashing their lamps in the dark, we created a rapid, scintillating beat, steady punctuated by small irregularities–the way we imagine Nature to be.

Next, we composed a jaunty “firefly theme song,” orchestrated for dulcimer. Peter suggested including an almost-identical melody as a second version of the theme. Again, the almost-but-not-quite-the-same quality of living beings.

We had our musical fireflies, but not the world they inhabit. To portray the beauty and mystery of the nocturnal forest, we composed a bass line of “forest music.”

A breeze blowing through the grove:

Add a sprinkling of pixie dust:

With the musical building blocks for our world in hand, we went to work, first establishing the mood of the forest at night, a place of mystery that erupts with rapturous swarming dance of fireflies. Things get a little wild!

Categories
News Projects Uncategorized

A space for creating music

By June Kinoshita, Executive Director

This past month, Tod Machover and I were invited to give a workshop to introduce Hyperscore and music composition at Projectory, in Seoul, Korea. Projectory is a center established by NC Cultural Foundation for the purpose of providing a space for children to give free play to their creativity without interference from adults. While South Korea’s public education system is regarded as among the best in the world, critics say it is too test-driven and brutally competitive. At Projectory, members are free to direct their own activities in any way they choose. They work with “crew members,” young adult mentors who are trained to support the children without prescribing what they should do.

In our workshop, Tod introduced the idea of composing as a form of personal expression and story-telling that could be about “anything you want.” Using a large projection screen, I then showed the basic features of Hyperscore.

The kids were then off to the races! They worked in groups of 2 or 3 brainstorming with paper and crayons to come up with topics ranging from baseball to fighting cats. They then shared laptops to compose their first-ever original tunes. We were all delighted by the results and later heard that the children are eager to keep composing. We’re excited to see if Hyperscore will take root and spread in Korea.

Here’s “RBR,” composed by Projectory members.

Categories
Read Resources

DIY Workshop

If you’re interested in trying out Hyperscore to teach music composition but are not ready or able to fully commit, this article is for you. This is for the retired educator who wants to help out his daughter who is homeschooling her kids. This is for the teacher who doesn’t have it in her budget this year but is eager to find a way to engage the kids in her classroom now. This is for the nonprofit foundation that wants to run a music camp next summer. This is for the after school club seeking an exciting project….

Step one. Decide if everyone will gather around a single computer or if everyone will have their own device.

Step two. Each device / individual should sign up for the Free Trial version of Hyperscore.

Step three. Decide on the type of composing activity you want to lead. Most can be done as collaborative or individual activities. Check out our blog for ideas.

Pro tip 1: The free trial version of Hyperscore cannot save more than five compositions in the cloud, so remind participants to download and save their compositions locally on their device.

Pro tip 2: Let the participants lead the way. Your role is to encourage exploration and discussion. There’s no right or wrong way. Be the guide on their side, not the sage on the stage.

If you are using Hyperscore successfully and wish to continue, we recommend a basic, premium, or supreme subscription. These are affordable options for small groups and will allow you to:

  • Create up to 5 user profiles
  • Save more scores (compositions)
  • Use more melody and sketch windows
  • Unlock different instrument sets
  • Unlock more themes
  • Export audio and MIDI output

If you would like to use Hyperscore in larger classrooms and manage your students’ work, we recommend that you license the classroom version through MusicFirst or by contacting us.

Categories
Read

Bach BOT

by June Kinoshita, Executive Director, New Harmony Line

Okay, I made up the title to riff on music AI, only to discover there really is a Bach Bot out there. It’s a system that uses AI to generate Bach-like music. I shouldn’t have been surprised. Music AI bots are proliferating alongside other generative AI programs. Major media and music companies are investing in AI-generated music, raising alarm among those who care about musical culture. 

In a recent article, the Washington Post reported, “AI music has found its way into the mainstream — you’ve probably heard a few seconds of it even today: soundtracking ads on YouTube and Facebook, or providing the emotional context of a TikTok video.” 

Some music AIs are designed to suck up all the music you listen to and generate more music that sounds similar but isn’t composed by an actual human. Think of all the royalty fees these companies won’t have to pay. Other companies are developing algorithms to generate tunes that will optimize your mental state.

But can such sounds, generated without any human intention, without a living person trying to communicate their experiences and emotions, be considered art? With art, it takes two to tango. You need an artist with an intention to provoke a response, and a recipient who brings their own sensibilities to bear on how they respond. Intention and framing matter. That’s why John Cage’s 4’33, the piece that famously asks you to listen intentionally to the world around you for four minutes and 33 seconds, is art while my silent procrastination is not. When I sit through a performance of 4’33, the composer is communicating with me, even if the man is no longer living. Without the artist mediating the experience, it’s just me projecting.

“Pieces of music aren’t just pieces of sound,” says Tod Machover, the composer and co-founder of New Harmony Line.. “They’re because some human being thought something was important to communicate and express.”

There is an appropriate place for AI in music, says Machover. In his own work, “I try to make models that are productive and useful and interesting and beautiful,” he says, “and I personally believe in a kind of collaboration between people and technology.”

This belief helps us appreciate Machover’s intention behind the creation of Hyperscore. Here is a tool that utilizes technology to remove barriers to music composition. That doesn’t mean it automates the process of composition. Hyperscore takes away the parts that untrained musicians find hard and leaves the kernel that is most important: What is it you need to say? 

In a world where we are losing more and more of the human touch, where nearly everything we use in daily life, from our clothes, work tools, and food, is manufactured by machines, we crave ways to express and celebrate our human moments. Witness the explosion of interest in preparing food, knitting, DIY projects.

People are hungry for channels to express themselves creatively. Music is among the most direct, powerful ways to tell our stories. We must elevate and celebrate authentic, human music by supporting artists, music education, and the means for everyone to participate.

Coda

Just after posting this, I was struck by the irony that I had used an image (below) that I had generated using DALL-E (“Baroque-style etching of J.S. Bach as a robot”). It was fun, but I agonized over whether I was unknowingly stealing bits actual artists’ work or undermining the market in which they made their living. Is there a place for AI-generated illustrations? What do you think?